FhSim  3.1.0
Marine systems simulation
Loading...
Searching...
No Matches
Validation: a3/b4 consistency and refit (L9)

Table of Contents

Whether the default angle harmonics a3 = 0.017, a5 = 0.053, b4 = 0.092, b6 = 0.105 of LocalThroughFlow satisfy the independent angle data (Rudi L5, Zhan L8), and the least-squares refit over MF2022, Rudi and Zhan. The refit is reported only; the law is not tuned (lead ruling R20). Data: Validation: MF2022 towed panels (L1-L4), Validation: Rudi 1988 and Løland 1991 (L5, L6), Validation: Zhan 2006 planar nets (L8).

Known misfit, disclosed by owner decision (2026-09-27; lift revised by the ruling of 2026-10-13, MARE-0110; drag angle form revised by the ruling of 2026-10-20, ENV-0120; lift angle form by the ruling of 2026-10-21, ENV-0125). The default law LocalThroughFlow takes its lift from the MF2022 Eq. 10 lift-to-drag ratio and agrees with MF2022 at 0° and 45°. Its drag angle form is option O1 of the ENV-0120 prototype, a3 = 0.017 and a5 = 0.053 (a3 + a5 = 0.07 keeps 0° and 45°); it still misses Rudi and Zhan at 30–80° by 0.002–0.006 in four rows (about Rudi's digitising error, accepted by the owner; ENV-0120 is resolved). The lift angle form follows Rudi with a sixth harmonic pinned at 45°, b4 = 0.092 and b6 = 0.105 (ENV-0125, resolved); three Rudi rows still fail (Sn 0.144 at 80°, Sn 0.317 at 60° and 80°), and Løland's pure sin 2θ is not followed. Zhan's speed trend is put down to frame deformation, not to the panel law. 3 load-law tests fail and stay DISABLED_, each with its reason in 11.4 The default law's lift and angle form against the data (MARE-0110, MARE-0131); nothing is tuned to pass them.

Generated 2026-10-22 from commit e12656c 2026-10-22 (with uncommitted changes under src/ or tests/); tests run 2026-10-22T11:39:52.126.

Tests

Status from the gtest XML of the last run. A DISABLED_ test fails against the current laws; its numbers are in the tables below, and it stays disabled until the owner decides the issue.

Test Source Status Issues Owner question
PanelLoadLaw_Consistency.DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8 PanelLoadLaw_Consistency_Test.cpp:219 DISABLED (fails when run) ENV-0120 (resolved), ENV-0125 (resolved), MARE-0110 (fhsim_marine_elements, resolved); none open –
PanelLoadLaw_Consistency.L9_RefitOfA3AndB4IsReported PanelLoadLaw_Consistency_Test.cpp:151 passed – –

PanelLoadLaw A3B4 fit

tests/out/PanelLoadLaw_A3B4_fit.txt, as the test wrote it.

PanelLoadLaw a3/b4 refit (plan L9, MARE-0093). Reported only; the law is not tuned.

Conventions: error = model/measured - 1 (in %) for loads and coefficients, model - measured for ratios and localCd; ratio = measured/model; margin = tolerance - |error| (negative = fails).

Model: LocalThroughFlow, C_D(theta) = cd ((1 - a3 - a5) cos theta + a3 cos 3 theta + a5 cos 5 theta), a5 held at its default, C_L(theta) = cl ((1 + b6) sin 2 theta + b4 sin 4 theta + b6 sin 6 theta), b6 held at its default. Unweighted least squares on absolute ratio residuals.

Fit data: MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at Rn = 2000 (8 Table 2 nets); Rudi (KF2012 Fig. 5) all points; Zhan R30/R0 and R60/R0 at 0.5-1.0 m/s, K = 1. a3 from the drag ratios, b4 from the Rudi lift ratios (the other two datasets carry no b4 information).

Defaults (contract C2): a3 = 0.0170, a5 = 0.0530, b4 = 0.0920, b6 = 0.1050

Refit over all datasets: a3 = 0.0114 (50 points), b4 = 0.0924 (24 points)

Per-dataset fits:

MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0), 8 nets a3 alone = 0.0187 ( 8 points)
Rudi C_D(theta)/C_D(0) a3 alone = 0.0045 (24 points)
Zhan R30/R0, R60/R0 (0.5-1.0 m/s, K = 1) a3 alone = 0.0125 (18 points)
Rudi C_L(theta)/C_L(45) b4 alone = 0.0924 (24 points)

Residuals:

MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0), 8 nets RMS(model - measured): default 0.0109, refit 0.0149
Rudi C_D(theta)/C_D(0) RMS(model - measured): default 0.0421, refit 0.0409
Zhan R30/R0, R60/R0 (0.5-1.0 m/s, K = 1) RMS(model - measured): default 0.0547, refit 0.0544
Rudi C_L(theta)/C_L(45) RMS(model - measured): default 0.0622, refit 0.0622

L9 checks (L5 tolerance 0.08, L8 ratio tolerance 0.10): 7 of 66 fail at the defaults, 6 of 66 fail at the refit.

L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8)

DISABLED test; 66 rows, 7 of 66 outside the tolerance.

Chart: L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8); L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported).

Model minus measurement per case with the tolerance band L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8) L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported) L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported) -0.2 -0.1 0 0.1 model − measured; shaded: tolerance Sn 0.130 CD( 0)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CD( 0)/CD(0): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CD( 0)/CD(0): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CD(30)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CD(30)/CD(0): measured 0.845, model 0.7595, error -0.085, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CD(30)/CD(0): measured 0.845, model 0.7644, error -0.081, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CD(45)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.655, model 0.6081, error -0.047, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.655, model 0.6161, error -0.039, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CD(60)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CD(60)/CD(0): measured 0.483, model 0.4745, error -0.008, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CD(60)/CD(0): measured 0.483, model 0.4829, error -0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CD(80)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CD(80)/CD(0): measured 0.276, model 0.1936, error -0.082, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CD(80)/CD(0): measured 0.276, model 0.1974, error -0.079, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CD(90)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CD(90)/CD(0): measured 0, model 7.005e-17, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CD(90)/CD(0): measured 0, model 7.143e-17, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CD( 0)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CD( 0)/CD(0): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CD( 0)/CD(0): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CD(30)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CD(30)/CD(0): measured 0.778, model 0.7595, error -0.018, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CD(30)/CD(0): measured 0.778, model 0.7644, error -0.014, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CD(45)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.635, model 0.6081, error -0.027, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.635, model 0.6161, error -0.019, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CD(60)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CD(60)/CD(0): measured 0.492, model 0.4745, error -0.018, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CD(60)/CD(0): measured 0.492, model 0.4829, error -0.009, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CD(80)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CD(80)/CD(0): measured 0.238, model 0.1936, error -0.044, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CD(80)/CD(0): measured 0.238, model 0.1974, error -0.041, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CD(90)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CD(90)/CD(0): measured 0.032, model 7.005e-17, error -0.032, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CD(90)/CD(0): measured 0.032, model 7.143e-17, error -0.032, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CD( 0)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CD( 0)/CD(0): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CD( 0)/CD(0): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CD(30)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CD(30)/CD(0): measured 0.736, model 0.7595, error 0.024, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CD(30)/CD(0): measured 0.736, model 0.7644, error 0.028, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CD(45)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.626, model 0.6081, error -0.018, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.626, model 0.6161, error -0.010, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CD(60)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CD(60)/CD(0): measured 0.549, model 0.4745, error -0.074, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CD(60)/CD(0): measured 0.549, model 0.4829, error -0.066, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CD(80)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CD(80)/CD(0): measured 0.231, model 0.1936, error -0.037, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CD(80)/CD(0): measured 0.231, model 0.1974, error -0.034, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CD(90)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CD(90)/CD(0): measured 0.011, model 7.005e-17, error -0.011, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CD(90)/CD(0): measured 0.011, model 7.143e-17, error -0.011, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CD( 0)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CD( 0)/CD(0): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CD( 0)/CD(0): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CD(30)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CD(30)/CD(0): measured 0.792, model 0.7595, error -0.032, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CD(30)/CD(0): measured 0.792, model 0.7644, error -0.028, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CD(45)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.575, model 0.6081, error 0.033, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.575, model 0.6161, error 0.041, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CD(60)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CD(60)/CD(0): measured 0.389, model 0.4745, error 0.086, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CD(60)/CD(0): measured 0.389, model 0.4829, error 0.094, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CD(80)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CD(80)/CD(0): measured 0.131, model 0.1936, error 0.063, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CD(80)/CD(0): measured 0.131, model 0.1974, error 0.066, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CD(90)/CD(0) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CD(90)/CD(0): measured 0.023, model 7.005e-17, error -0.023, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CD(90)/CD(0): measured 0.023, model 7.143e-17, error -0.023, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CL( 0)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CL( 0)/CL(45): measured 0, model 0, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CL( 0)/CL(45): measured 0, model 0, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CL(30)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CL(30)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1.037, error 0.037, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CL(30)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1.037, error 0.037, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CL(45)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CL(45)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CL(45)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CL(60)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CL(60)/CL(45): measured 0.909, model 0.8773, error -0.032, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CL(60)/CL(45): measured 0.909, model 0.8769, error -0.032, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CL(80)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CL(80)/CL(45): measured 0.455, model 0.4097, error -0.045, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CL(80)/CL(45): measured 0.455, model 0.4094, error -0.046, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.130 CL(90)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.130 CL(90)/CL(45): measured 0, model 1.514e-16, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.130 CL(90)/CL(45): measured 0, model 1.513e-16, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CL( 0)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CL( 0)/CL(45): measured 0, model 0, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CL( 0)/CL(45): measured 0, model 0, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CL(30)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CL(30)/CL(45): measured 1.091, model 1.037, error -0.054, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CL(30)/CL(45): measured 1.091, model 1.037, error -0.054, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CL(45)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CL(45)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CL(45)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CL(60)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CL(60)/CL(45): measured 0.909, model 0.8773, error -0.032, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CL(60)/CL(45): measured 0.909, model 0.8769, error -0.032, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CL(80)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CL(80)/CL(45): measured 0.636, model 0.4097, error -0.226, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CL(80)/CL(45): measured 0.636, model 0.4094, error -0.227, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.144 CL(90)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.144 CL(90)/CL(45): measured 0, model 1.514e-16, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.144 CL(90)/CL(45): measured 0, model 1.513e-16, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CL( 0)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CL( 0)/CL(45): measured 0, model 0, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CL( 0)/CL(45): measured 0, model 0, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CL(30)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CL(30)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1.037, error 0.037, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CL(30)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1.037, error 0.037, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CL(45)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CL(45)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CL(45)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CL(60)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CL(60)/CL(45): measured 0.8, model 0.8773, error 0.077, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CL(60)/CL(45): measured 0.8, model 0.8769, error 0.077, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CL(80)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CL(80)/CL(45): measured 0.35, model 0.4097, error 0.060, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CL(80)/CL(45): measured 0.35, model 0.4094, error 0.059, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.184 CL(90)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.184 CL(90)/CL(45): measured 0, model 1.514e-16, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.184 CL(90)/CL(45): measured 0, model 1.513e-16, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CL( 0)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CL( 0)/CL(45): measured 0, model 0, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CL( 0)/CL(45): measured 0, model 0, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CL(30)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CL(30)/CL(45): measured 1.019, model 1.037, error 0.018, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CL(30)/CL(45): measured 1.019, model 1.037, error 0.018, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CL(45)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CL(45)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CL(45)/CL(45): measured 1, model 1, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CL(60)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CL(60)/CL(45): measured 0.769, model 0.8773, error 0.108, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CL(60)/CL(45): measured 0.769, model 0.8769, error 0.108, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CL(80)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CL(80)/CL(45): measured 0.308, model 0.4097, error 0.102, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CL(80)/CL(45): measured 0.308, model 0.4094, error 0.101, tolerance ±0.08 Sn 0.317 CL(90)/CL(45) L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): Sn 0.317 CL(90)/CL(45): measured 0, model 1.514e-16, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): Sn 0.317 CL(90)/CL(45): measured 0, model 1.513e-16, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.08 s 0.223 v 0.50 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.223 v 0.50 R30/R0: measured 0.8231, model 0.7595, error -0.064, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.223 v 0.50 R30/R0: measured 0.8231, model 0.7644, error -0.059, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.223 v 0.50 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.223 v 0.50 R60/R0: measured 0.5052, model 0.4745, error -0.031, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.223 v 0.50 R60/R0: measured 0.5052, model 0.4829, error -0.022, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.223 v 0.75 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.223 v 0.75 R30/R0: measured 0.7669, model 0.7595, error -0.007, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.223 v 0.75 R30/R0: measured 0.7669, model 0.7644, error -0.003, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.223 v 0.75 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.223 v 0.75 R60/R0: measured 0.5445, model 0.4745, error -0.070, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.223 v 0.75 R60/R0: measured 0.5445, model 0.4829, error -0.062, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.223 v 1.00 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.223 v 1.00 R30/R0: measured 0.8249, model 0.7595, error -0.065, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.223 v 1.00 R30/R0: measured 0.8249, model 0.7644, error -0.061, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.223 v 1.00 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.223 v 1.00 R60/R0: measured 0.5791, model 0.4745, error -0.105, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.223 v 1.00 R60/R0: measured 0.5791, model 0.4829, error -0.096, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.128 v 0.50 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.128 v 0.50 R30/R0: measured 0.7708, model 0.7595, error -0.011, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.128 v 0.50 R30/R0: measured 0.7708, model 0.7644, error -0.006, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.128 v 0.50 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.128 v 0.50 R60/R0: measured 0.4048, model 0.4745, error 0.070, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.128 v 0.50 R60/R0: measured 0.4048, model 0.4829, error 0.078, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.128 v 0.75 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.128 v 0.75 R30/R0: measured 0.6742, model 0.7595, error 0.085, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.128 v 0.75 R30/R0: measured 0.6742, model 0.7644, error 0.090, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.128 v 0.75 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.128 v 0.75 R60/R0: measured 0.4541, model 0.4745, error 0.020, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.128 v 0.75 R60/R0: measured 0.4541, model 0.4829, error 0.029, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.128 v 1.00 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.128 v 1.00 R30/R0: measured 0.7756, model 0.7595, error -0.016, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.128 v 1.00 R30/R0: measured 0.7756, model 0.7644, error -0.011, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.128 v 1.00 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.128 v 1.00 R60/R0: measured 0.5141, model 0.4745, error -0.040, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.128 v 1.00 R60/R0: measured 0.5141, model 0.4829, error -0.031, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.215 v 0.50 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.215 v 0.50 R30/R0: measured 0.759, model 0.7595, error 0.000, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.215 v 0.50 R30/R0: measured 0.759, model 0.7644, error 0.005, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.215 v 0.50 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.215 v 0.50 R60/R0: measured 0.3769, model 0.4745, error 0.098, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.215 v 0.50 R60/R0: measured 0.3769, model 0.4829, error 0.106, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.215 v 0.75 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.215 v 0.75 R30/R0: measured 0.7313, model 0.7595, error 0.028, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.215 v 0.75 R30/R0: measured 0.7313, model 0.7644, error 0.033, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.215 v 0.75 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.215 v 0.75 R60/R0: measured 0.4376, model 0.4745, error 0.037, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.215 v 0.75 R60/R0: measured 0.4376, model 0.4829, error 0.045, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.215 v 1.00 R30/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.215 v 1.00 R30/R0: measured 0.8092, model 0.7595, error -0.050, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.215 v 1.00 R30/R0: measured 0.8092, model 0.7644, error -0.045, tolerance ±0.1 s 0.215 v 1.00 R60/R0 L9 at the defaults a3 0.017, a5 0.053, b4 0.092, b6 0.105 (DISABLED_L9_DefaultHarmonicsSatisfyL5AndL8): s 0.215 v 1.00 R60/R0: measured 0.4771, model 0.4745, error -0.003, tolerance ±0.1 L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported): s 0.215 v 1.00 R60/R0: measured 0.4771, model 0.4829, error 0.006, tolerance ±0.1

Case Measured Model Error Tolerance Margin Result
Sn 0.130 CD( 0)/CD(0) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.130 CD(30)/CD(0) 0.845 0.7595 -0.085 ±0.08 -0.005 outside
Sn 0.130 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.655 0.6081 -0.047 ±0.08 0.033 within
Sn 0.130 CD(60)/CD(0) 0.483 0.4745 -0.008 ±0.08 0.072 within
Sn 0.130 CD(80)/CD(0) 0.276 0.1936 -0.082 ±0.08 -0.002 outside
Sn 0.130 CD(90)/CD(0) 0 7.005e-17 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CD( 0)/CD(0) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CD(30)/CD(0) 0.778 0.7595 -0.018 ±0.08 0.062 within
Sn 0.144 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.635 0.6081 -0.027 ±0.08 0.053 within
Sn 0.144 CD(60)/CD(0) 0.492 0.4745 -0.018 ±0.08 0.062 within
Sn 0.144 CD(80)/CD(0) 0.238 0.1936 -0.044 ±0.08 0.036 within
Sn 0.144 CD(90)/CD(0) 0.032 7.005e-17 -0.032 ±0.08 0.048 within
Sn 0.184 CD( 0)/CD(0) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.184 CD(30)/CD(0) 0.736 0.7595 0.024 ±0.08 0.056 within
Sn 0.184 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.626 0.6081 -0.018 ±0.08 0.062 within
Sn 0.184 CD(60)/CD(0) 0.549 0.4745 -0.074 ±0.08 0.006 within
Sn 0.184 CD(80)/CD(0) 0.231 0.1936 -0.037 ±0.08 0.043 within
Sn 0.184 CD(90)/CD(0) 0.011 7.005e-17 -0.011 ±0.08 0.069 within
Sn 0.317 CD( 0)/CD(0) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.317 CD(30)/CD(0) 0.792 0.7595 -0.032 ±0.08 0.048 within
Sn 0.317 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.575 0.6081 0.033 ±0.08 0.047 within
Sn 0.317 CD(60)/CD(0) 0.389 0.4745 0.086 ±0.08 -0.006 outside
Sn 0.317 CD(80)/CD(0) 0.131 0.1936 0.063 ±0.08 0.017 within
Sn 0.317 CD(90)/CD(0) 0.023 7.005e-17 -0.023 ±0.08 0.057 within
Sn 0.130 CL( 0)/CL(45) 0 0 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.130 CL(30)/CL(45) 1 1.037 0.037 ±0.08 0.043 within
Sn 0.130 CL(45)/CL(45) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.130 CL(60)/CL(45) 0.909 0.8773 -0.032 ±0.08 0.048 within
Sn 0.130 CL(80)/CL(45) 0.455 0.4097 -0.045 ±0.08 0.035 within
Sn 0.130 CL(90)/CL(45) 0 1.514e-16 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CL( 0)/CL(45) 0 0 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CL(30)/CL(45) 1.091 1.037 -0.054 ±0.08 0.026 within
Sn 0.144 CL(45)/CL(45) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CL(60)/CL(45) 0.909 0.8773 -0.032 ±0.08 0.048 within
Sn 0.144 CL(80)/CL(45) 0.636 0.4097 -0.226 ±0.08 -0.146 outside
Sn 0.144 CL(90)/CL(45) 0 1.514e-16 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.184 CL( 0)/CL(45) 0 0 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.184 CL(30)/CL(45) 1 1.037 0.037 ±0.08 0.043 within
Sn 0.184 CL(45)/CL(45) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.184 CL(60)/CL(45) 0.8 0.8773 0.077 ±0.08 0.003 within
Sn 0.184 CL(80)/CL(45) 0.35 0.4097 0.06 ±0.08 0.02 within
Sn 0.184 CL(90)/CL(45) 0 1.514e-16 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.317 CL( 0)/CL(45) 0 0 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.317 CL(30)/CL(45) 1.019 1.037 0.018 ±0.08 0.062 within
Sn 0.317 CL(45)/CL(45) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.317 CL(60)/CL(45) 0.769 0.8773 0.108 ±0.08 -0.028 outside
Sn 0.317 CL(80)/CL(45) 0.308 0.4097 0.102 ±0.08 -0.022 outside
Sn 0.317 CL(90)/CL(45) 0 1.514e-16 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
s 0.223 v 0.50 R30/R0 0.8231 0.7595 -0.064 ±0.1 0.036 within
s 0.223 v 0.50 R60/R0 0.5052 0.4745 -0.031 ±0.1 0.069 within
s 0.223 v 0.75 R30/R0 0.7669 0.7595 -0.007 ±0.1 0.093 within
s 0.223 v 0.75 R60/R0 0.5445 0.4745 -0.07 ±0.1 0.03 within
s 0.223 v 1.00 R30/R0 0.8249 0.7595 -0.065 ±0.1 0.035 within
s 0.223 v 1.00 R60/R0 0.5791 0.4745 -0.105 ±0.1 -0.005 outside
s 0.128 v 0.50 R30/R0 0.7708 0.7595 -0.011 ±0.1 0.089 within
s 0.128 v 0.50 R60/R0 0.4048 0.4745 0.07 ±0.1 0.03 within
s 0.128 v 0.75 R30/R0 0.6742 0.7595 0.085 ±0.1 0.015 within
s 0.128 v 0.75 R60/R0 0.4541 0.4745 0.02 ±0.1 0.08 within
s 0.128 v 1.00 R30/R0 0.7756 0.7595 -0.016 ±0.1 0.084 within
s 0.128 v 1.00 R60/R0 0.5141 0.4745 -0.04 ±0.1 0.06 within
s 0.215 v 0.50 R30/R0 0.759 0.7595 0 ±0.1 0.1 within
s 0.215 v 0.50 R60/R0 0.3769 0.4745 0.098 ±0.1 0.002 within
s 0.215 v 0.75 R30/R0 0.7313 0.7595 0.028 ±0.1 0.072 within
s 0.215 v 0.75 R60/R0 0.4376 0.4745 0.037 ±0.1 0.063 within
s 0.215 v 1.00 R30/R0 0.8092 0.7595 -0.05 ±0.1 0.05 within
s 0.215 v 1.00 R60/R0 0.4771 0.4745 -0.003 ±0.1 0.097 within

L9 at the refit a3 0.0114, b4 0.0924 (reported)

reported; 66 rows, 6 of 66 outside the tolerance.

Case Measured Model Error Tolerance Margin Result
Sn 0.130 CD( 0)/CD(0) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.130 CD(30)/CD(0) 0.845 0.7644 -0.081 ±0.08 -0.001 outside
Sn 0.130 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.655 0.6161 -0.039 ±0.08 0.041 within
Sn 0.130 CD(60)/CD(0) 0.483 0.4829 -0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.130 CD(80)/CD(0) 0.276 0.1974 -0.079 ±0.08 0.001 within
Sn 0.130 CD(90)/CD(0) 0 7.143e-17 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CD( 0)/CD(0) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CD(30)/CD(0) 0.778 0.7644 -0.014 ±0.08 0.066 within
Sn 0.144 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.635 0.6161 -0.019 ±0.08 0.061 within
Sn 0.144 CD(60)/CD(0) 0.492 0.4829 -0.009 ±0.08 0.071 within
Sn 0.144 CD(80)/CD(0) 0.238 0.1974 -0.041 ±0.08 0.039 within
Sn 0.144 CD(90)/CD(0) 0.032 7.143e-17 -0.032 ±0.08 0.048 within
Sn 0.184 CD( 0)/CD(0) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.184 CD(30)/CD(0) 0.736 0.7644 0.028 ±0.08 0.052 within
Sn 0.184 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.626 0.6161 -0.01 ±0.08 0.07 within
Sn 0.184 CD(60)/CD(0) 0.549 0.4829 -0.066 ±0.08 0.014 within
Sn 0.184 CD(80)/CD(0) 0.231 0.1974 -0.034 ±0.08 0.046 within
Sn 0.184 CD(90)/CD(0) 0.011 7.143e-17 -0.011 ±0.08 0.069 within
Sn 0.317 CD( 0)/CD(0) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.317 CD(30)/CD(0) 0.792 0.7644 -0.028 ±0.08 0.052 within
Sn 0.317 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.575 0.6161 0.041 ±0.08 0.039 within
Sn 0.317 CD(60)/CD(0) 0.389 0.4829 0.094 ±0.08 -0.014 outside
Sn 0.317 CD(80)/CD(0) 0.131 0.1974 0.066 ±0.08 0.014 within
Sn 0.317 CD(90)/CD(0) 0.023 7.143e-17 -0.023 ±0.08 0.057 within
Sn 0.130 CL( 0)/CL(45) 0 0 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.130 CL(30)/CL(45) 1 1.037 0.037 ±0.08 0.043 within
Sn 0.130 CL(45)/CL(45) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.130 CL(60)/CL(45) 0.909 0.8769 -0.032 ±0.08 0.048 within
Sn 0.130 CL(80)/CL(45) 0.455 0.4094 -0.046 ±0.08 0.034 within
Sn 0.130 CL(90)/CL(45) 0 1.513e-16 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CL( 0)/CL(45) 0 0 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CL(30)/CL(45) 1.091 1.037 -0.054 ±0.08 0.026 within
Sn 0.144 CL(45)/CL(45) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.144 CL(60)/CL(45) 0.909 0.8769 -0.032 ±0.08 0.048 within
Sn 0.144 CL(80)/CL(45) 0.636 0.4094 -0.227 ±0.08 -0.147 outside
Sn 0.144 CL(90)/CL(45) 0 1.513e-16 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.184 CL( 0)/CL(45) 0 0 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.184 CL(30)/CL(45) 1 1.037 0.037 ±0.08 0.043 within
Sn 0.184 CL(45)/CL(45) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.184 CL(60)/CL(45) 0.8 0.8769 0.077 ±0.08 0.003 within
Sn 0.184 CL(80)/CL(45) 0.35 0.4094 0.059 ±0.08 0.021 within
Sn 0.184 CL(90)/CL(45) 0 1.513e-16 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.317 CL( 0)/CL(45) 0 0 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.317 CL(30)/CL(45) 1.019 1.037 0.018 ±0.08 0.062 within
Sn 0.317 CL(45)/CL(45) 1 1 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
Sn 0.317 CL(60)/CL(45) 0.769 0.8769 0.108 ±0.08 -0.028 outside
Sn 0.317 CL(80)/CL(45) 0.308 0.4094 0.101 ±0.08 -0.021 outside
Sn 0.317 CL(90)/CL(45) 0 1.513e-16 0 ±0.08 0.08 within
s 0.223 v 0.50 R30/R0 0.8231 0.7644 -0.059 ±0.1 0.041 within
s 0.223 v 0.50 R60/R0 0.5052 0.4829 -0.022 ±0.1 0.078 within
s 0.223 v 0.75 R30/R0 0.7669 0.7644 -0.003 ±0.1 0.097 within
s 0.223 v 0.75 R60/R0 0.5445 0.4829 -0.062 ±0.1 0.038 within
s 0.223 v 1.00 R30/R0 0.8249 0.7644 -0.061 ±0.1 0.039 within
s 0.223 v 1.00 R60/R0 0.5791 0.4829 -0.096 ±0.1 0.004 within
s 0.128 v 0.50 R30/R0 0.7708 0.7644 -0.006 ±0.1 0.094 within
s 0.128 v 0.50 R60/R0 0.4048 0.4829 0.078 ±0.1 0.022 within
s 0.128 v 0.75 R30/R0 0.6742 0.7644 0.09 ±0.1 0.01 within
s 0.128 v 0.75 R60/R0 0.4541 0.4829 0.029 ±0.1 0.071 within
s 0.128 v 1.00 R30/R0 0.7756 0.7644 -0.011 ±0.1 0.089 within
s 0.128 v 1.00 R60/R0 0.5141 0.4829 -0.031 ±0.1 0.069 within
s 0.215 v 0.50 R30/R0 0.759 0.7644 0.005 ±0.1 0.095 within
s 0.215 v 0.50 R60/R0 0.3769 0.4829 0.106 ±0.1 -0.006 outside
s 0.215 v 0.75 R30/R0 0.7313 0.7644 0.033 ±0.1 0.067 within
s 0.215 v 0.75 R60/R0 0.4376 0.4829 0.045 ±0.1 0.055 within
s 0.215 v 1.00 R30/R0 0.8092 0.7644 -0.045 ±0.1 0.055 within
s 0.215 v 1.00 R60/R0 0.4771 0.4829 0.006 ±0.1 0.094 within

MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance)

reported; 8 rows, no tolerance.

Chart: MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance); MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance).

Model minus measurement per case with the tolerance band MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance) -0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 model − measured; shaded: tolerance N19a Snm 0.193 CD(45)/CD(0) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance): N19a Snm 0.193 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.6116, model 0.6081, error -0.003 MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance): N19a Snm 0.193 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.6116, model 0.6161, error 0.004 N26a Snm 0.262 CD(45)/CD(0) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance): N26a Snm 0.262 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.6161, model 0.6081, error -0.008 MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance): N26a Snm 0.262 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.6161, model 0.6161, error -0.000 N33a Snm 0.331 CD(45)/CD(0) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance): N33a Snm 0.331 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.5969, model 0.6081, error 0.011 MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance): N33a Snm 0.331 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.5969, model 0.6161, error 0.019 N36a Snm 0.364 CD(45)/CD(0) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance): N36a Snm 0.364 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.5849, model 0.6081, error 0.023 MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance): N36a Snm 0.364 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.5849, model 0.6161, error 0.031 N18b Snm 0.185 CD(45)/CD(0) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance): N18b Snm 0.185 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.6074, model 0.6081, error 0.001 MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance): N18b Snm 0.185 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.6074, model 0.6161, error 0.009 N20b Snm 0.199 CD(45)/CD(0) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance): N20b Snm 0.199 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.614, model 0.6081, error -0.006 MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance): N20b Snm 0.199 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.614, model 0.6161, error 0.002 N26b Snm 0.257 CD(45)/CD(0) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance): N26b Snm 0.257 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.6169, model 0.6081, error -0.009 MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance): N26b Snm 0.257 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.6169, model 0.6161, error -0.001 N33b Snm 0.328 CD(45)/CD(0) MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the defaults (fit data, no tolerance): N33b Snm 0.328 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.5979, model 0.6081, error 0.010 MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance): N33b Snm 0.328 CD(45)/CD(0): measured 0.5979, model 0.6161, error 0.018

Case Measured Model Error Tolerance Margin Result
N19a Snm 0.193 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.6116 0.6081 -0.003 – – reported
N26a Snm 0.262 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.6161 0.6081 -0.008 – – reported
N33a Snm 0.331 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.5969 0.6081 0.011 – – reported
N36a Snm 0.364 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.5849 0.6081 0.023 – – reported
N18b Snm 0.185 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.6074 0.6081 0.001 – – reported
N20b Snm 0.199 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.614 0.6081 -0.006 – – reported
N26b Snm 0.257 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.6169 0.6081 -0.009 – – reported
N33b Snm 0.328 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.5979 0.6081 0.01 – – reported

MF2022 Eq. 10 CD(45)/CD(0) at the refit (fit data, no tolerance)

reported; 8 rows, no tolerance.

Case Measured Model Error Tolerance Margin Result
N19a Snm 0.193 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.6116 0.6161 0.004 – – reported
N26a Snm 0.262 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.6161 0.6161 -0 – – reported
N33a Snm 0.331 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.5969 0.6161 0.019 – – reported
N36a Snm 0.364 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.5849 0.6161 0.031 – – reported
N18b Snm 0.185 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.6074 0.6161 0.009 – – reported
N20b Snm 0.199 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.614 0.6161 0.002 – – reported
N26b Snm 0.257 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.6169 0.6161 -0.001 – – reported
N33b Snm 0.328 CD(45)/CD(0) 0.5979 0.6161 0.018 – – reported